The four steps behind every review

1. We get the product in hand

We photograph the actual bottle ourselves — packaging, size, what comes in the box — not images pulled from a brand's press kit. When a product is provided by a brand or PR, the review says so plainly.

2. We check what's really in it

We read the full ingredient list the brand publishes and compare it with the claims on the label. If a claim isn't backed by what's in the bottle, we say so.

3. We gather what real users report

Skincare works differently from one face to the next, so one person's opinion is never enough. We read what people who have used the product report — across retailer reviews, community discussions, and other reviewers — and look for the patterns: what most people love, what keeps coming up as a complaint, and which skin types it suits or doesn't. Every point we make traces back to a source we keep on record, with the date we checked it.

4. An editor checks every review before it's published

Nothing goes live straight from research. An editor reads every review, checks the sources, corrects anything that doesn't hold up, and signs it off. When we have used a product ourselves, the review says so clearly.

The dew-drop score

Each review ends with a dew-drop score, built from four equally weighted questions:

  • Formula & feel — texture, scent, how it layers, how it wears.
  • Results reported — does it do what the label says it's designed to do, according to the people who use it?
  • Value for money — cost per use, compared honestly with alternatives.
  • Worth buying — the question that matters most: would we tell a friend to buy it?
5 — Holy grail. An easy recommendation.
4 — Really good. Recommended, with minor caveats.
3 — Solid. Works, but there are better options for the price.
2 — Underwhelming. Doesn't live up to its promises for most people.
1 — Skip it. We'll tell you why.

What we won't do

  • Claim we've used a product when we haven't.
  • Let a commission, a brand, or an affiliate program shape a score.
  • Make medical claims. Skincare results vary from skin to skin — we describe what a product is designed to do and what people report.

Questions about our process? Ask us anything.